Research status of small incision lenticule extraction in astigmatism

doi:10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-2007.2022.01.011

Abstract

Abstract:

The effectiveness, predictability and security of small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) on the correction of myopia have approved for clinicans after many years of usage. However, the correction of astigmatism was not as good as that of myopia with the corneal refractive surgeries, including SMILE. With the improvement of surgical techniques, methods and devices, the correction of astigmatism and myopic astigmatism with SMILE has recently changed.

Key words: Small incision lenticule extraction, Myopia, Astigmatism

Xiaoguang Cao, Yanling He, Yongzhen Bao, Kai Wang, Mingwei Zhao. Research status of small incision lenticule extraction in astigmatism[J]. Chinese Journal of Ophthalmologic Medicine(Electronic Edition), 2022, 12(01): 57-62.

/ / Recommend

Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

URL: https://zhykyxzz.cma-cmc.com.cn/EN/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-2007.2022.01.011

https://zhykyxzz.cma-cmc.com.cn/EN/Y2022/V12/I01/57

Figures/Tables 1

References 55

[1]	Chan TC, Ng AL, Cheng GP, et al. Vector analysis of astigmatic correction after small-incision lenticule extraction and femtosecond-assisted LASIK for low to moderate myopic astigmatism[J]. Br J Ophthalmol, 2016, 100(4): 553-559.
[2]	Han T, Xu Y, Han X, et al. Three-year outcomes of small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) and femtosecond laser-assisted laser in situ keratomileusis (FS-LASIK) for myopia and myopic astigmatism[J]. Br J Ophthalmol, 2019, 103(4): 565-568.
[3]	Yesilkaya C, Arc M, Yldrm Y, et al. Short and long term outcomes after small-incision lenticule extraction: A tertiary referral centre experience[J]. J Fr Ophtalmol, 2020, 43(8): 753-760.
[4]	Huang G, Melki S. Small Incision Lenticule Extraction (SMILE): Myths and Realities[J]. Semin Ophthalmol, 2021, 36(4): 140-148.
[5]	Liu M, Chen Y, Wang D, et al. Clinical Outcomes After SMILE and Femtosecond Laser-Assisted LASIK for Myopia and Myopic Astigmatism: A Prospective Randomized Comparative Study[J]. Cornea, 2016, 35(2): 210-216.
[6]	Authors Rose KSCF, Ryan DS, Beydoun H, et al. Small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) in the U．S. military: A prospective study of visual and military task performance[J]. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2021, 47(12): 1503-1510.
[7]	Zhao PF, Hu YB, Wang Y, et al. Comparison of correcting myopia and astigmatism with SMILE or FS-LASIK and postoperative higher-order aberrations[J]. Int J Ophthalmol, 2021, 14(4): 523-528.
[8]	Xia F, Qin B, Shang J, et al. Four-Year Outcomes of Small Incision Lenticule Extraction for Extreme High Myopia and Myopic Astigmatism[J]. Front Med (Lausanne), 2020, 7: 575779.
[9]	Blum M, Täubig K, Gruhn C, et al. Five-year results of Small Incision Lenticule Extraction (ReLEx SMILE)[J]. Br J Ophthalmol, 2016, 100(9): 1192-1195.
[10]	Hou X, Du K, Wen D, et al. Early visual quality outcomes after small-incision lenticule extraction surgery for correcting high myopic astigmatism[J]. BMC Ophthalmol, 2021, 21(1): 48.
[11]	Taneri S, Kießler S, Rost A, et al. Small-incision lenticule extraction for the correction of myopic astigmatism[J]. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2019, 45(1): 62-71.
[12]	Sánchez-González JM, Alonso-Aliste F. Visual and refractive outcomes of 100 small incision lenticule extractions (SMILE) in moderate and high myopia: a 24-month follow-up study[J]. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol, 2019, 257(7): 1561-1567.
[13]	Chen P, Ye Y, Yu N, et al. Correction of Astigmatism With SMILE With Axis Alignment: 6-Month Results From 622 Eyes[J]. J Refract Surg, 2019, 35(3): 138-145.
[14]	Chan TCY, Wang Y, Ng ALK, et al. Vector analysis of high (≥3 diopters) astigmatism correction using small-incision lenticule extraction and laser in situ keratomileusis[J]. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2018, 44(7): 802-810.
[15]	Ivarsen A, Gyldenkerne A, Hjortdal J. Correction of astigmatism with small-incision lenticule extraction: Impact of against-the-rule and with-the-rule astigmatism[J]. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2018, 44(9): 1066-1072.
[16]	Zhong Y, Li M, Han T, et al. Four-year outcomes of small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) to correct high myopic astigmatism[J]. Br J Ophthalmol, 2020, 16(7): 575779.
[17]	Ganesh S, Brar S, Pawar A. Results of Intraoperative Manual Cyclotorsion Compensation for Myopic Astigmatism in Patients Undergoing Small Incision Lenticule Extraction (SMILE)[J]. J Refract Surg, 2017, 33(8): 506-512.
[18]	Jun I, Kang DSY, Reinstein DZ, et al. Clinical Outcomes of SMILE With a Triple Centration Technique and Corneal Wavefront-Guided Transepithelial PRK in High Astigmatism[J]. J Refract Surg, 2018, 34(3): 156-163.
[19]	Zhang J, Wang Y, Chen X. Comparison of Moderate- to High-Astigmatism Corrections Using WaveFront-Guided Laser In Situ Keratomileusis and Small-Incision Lenticule Extraction[J]. Cornea, 2016, 35(4): 523-530.
[20]	Hiep NX, Khanh PTM, Quyet D, et al. Outcomes of Small Incision Lenticule Extraction for Myopic Astigmatic Treatment[J]. Open Access Maced J Med Sci, 2019, 7(24): 4272-4277.
[21]	Khalifa MA, Ghoneim AM, Shaheen MS, et al. Vector analysis of astigmatic changes after small-incision lenticule extraction and wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis[J]. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2017, 43(6): 819-824.
[22]	Dishler JG, Slade S, Seifert S, et al. Small-Incision Lenticule Extraction for the Correction of Myopia with Astigmatism: Outcomes of the United States Food and Drug Administration Premarket Approval Clinical Trial[J]. Ophthalmology, 2020，127(8): 1020-1034.
[23]	Blum M, Lauer AS, Kunert KS, et al. 10-Year Results of Small Incision Lenticule Extraction[J]. J Refract Surg, 2019, 35(10): 618-623.
[24]	Huang J, Zhou X, Qian Y. Decentration following femtosecond laser small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) in eyes with high astigmatism and its impact on visual quality[J]. BMC Ophthalmol, 2019, 19(1): 151.
[25]	李庆和，李岳美，齐绍文. SMILE治疗大散光2a的疗效观察[J]. 国际眼科杂志，2018, 18(6): 1153-1156.
[26]	Pérez-Izquierdo R, Rodríguez-Vallejo M, Matamoros A, et al. Influence of Preoperative Astigmatism Type and Magnitude on the Effectiveness of SMILE Correction[J]. J Refract Surg, 2019, 35(1): 40-47.
[27]	Yildiz BK, Urdem U, Goksel Ulas M, et al. Correction of myopic astigmatism by small incision lenticule extraction: does laterality matter？[J]. Lasers Med Sci, 2019, 34(2): 311-316.
[28]	Gyldenkerne A, Hjortdal J, Ivarsen A. Astigmatism prediction in small-incision lenticule extraction[J]. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2020, 46(4): 524-533.
[29]	Moshirfar M, Thomson AC, West WB, et al. Initial Single-Site Experience Using SMILE for the Treatment of Astigmatism in Myopic Eyes and Comparison of Astigmatic Outcomes with Existing Literature[J]. Clin Ophthalmol, 2020, 14: 3551-3562.
[30]	Zhang R, Wei H, Jhanji V, et al. Comparison of corneal aberrations and refractive outcomes after small-incision lenticule extraction and femtosecond-assisted laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis[J]. Int Ophthalmol, 2021，41(7)：2521-2531.
[31]	Piñero DP, Teus MA. Clinical outcomes of small-incision lenticule extraction and femtosecond laser-assisted wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis[J]. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2016, 42(7): 1078-1093.
[32]	Park S, Kim H, Kim L, et al. Artificial intelligence-based nomogram for small-incision lenticule extraction[J]. Biomed Eng Online, 2021, 20(1): 38.
[33]	陈鹏，宁英慧，陈文娟. Smile手术矫正中高度近视散光临床效果观察[J]. 中国药物与临床，2020, 20(1): 92-94.
[34]	Tülü Aygün B, Çankaya K, Aĝca A, et al. Five-year outcomes of small-incision lenticule extraction vs femtosecond laser-assisted laser in situ keratomileusis: a contralateral eye study[J]. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2020, 46(3): 403-409.
[35]	Schallhorn JM, Seifert S, Schallhorn SC. SMILE, Topography-Guided LASIK, and Wavefront-Guided LASIK: Review of Clinical Outcomes in Premarket Approval FDA Studies[J]. J Refract Surg, 2019, 35(11): 690-698.
[36]	刘莛，曹开伟，余婷，等. 角膜地形图引导的准分子激光手术与全飞秒激光微透镜取出术矫正不对称角膜散光的疗效观察[J]. 中华眼视光学与视觉科学杂志，2019, 21(10): 759-768.
[37]	Zheng Z, Zhang M, Jhanji V, et al. Comparison between aberration-free transepithelial photorefractive keratectomy and small incision lenticule extraction for correction of myopia and myopic astigmatism[J]. Int Ophthalmol, 2021, 41(1): 303-314.
[38]	Gulmez M, Tekce A, Kams U. Comparison of refractive outcomes and high-order aberrations after small incision lenticule extraction and wavefront-guided femtosecond-assisted laser in situ keratomileusis for correcting high myopia and myopic astigmatism[J]. Int Ophthalmol, 2020, 40(12): 3481-3489.
[39]	Zhao X, Zhang L, Ma J, et al. Comparison of Wavefront-Guided Femtosecond LASIK and Optimized SMILE for Correction of Moderate-to-High Astigmatism[J]. J Refract Surg, 2021, 37(3): 166-173.
[40]	Yang LJ, Liu X, Mi SJ, et al. Early visual function outcomes of topography-guided FS-LASIK and SMILE in treatment of myopia and myopic astigmatism[J]. Int J Ophthalmol, 2021, 14(3): 423-429.
[41]	Wan T, Yin H, Wu Z, et al. Vector analysis of small incision lenticule extraction and toric implantable collamer lens implantation for astigmatism correction[J]. Eur J Ophthalmol, 2021, 31(3): 994-1001.
[42]	Moshirfar M, Somani AN, Motlagh MN, et al. Comparison of FDA-Reported Visual and Refractive Outcomes of the Toric ICL Lens, SMILE, and Topography-Guided LASIK for the Correction of Myopia and Myopic Astigmatism[J]. J Refract Surg, 2019, 35(11): 699-706.
[43]	Ganesh S, Brar S, Pawar A. Matched population comparison of visual outcomes and patient satisfaction between 3 modalities for the correction of low to moderate myopic astigmatism[J]. Clin Ophthalmol, 2017, 11：1253-1263.
[44]	Han T, Shang J, Zhou X, et al. Refractive outcomes comparing small-incision lenticule extraction and femtosecond laser-assisted laser in situ keratomileusis for high myopia[J]. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2020, 46(3): 419-427.
[45]	Wu F, Yin H, Chen X, et al. Investigation of predictability and influence factors of the achieved lenticule thickness in small incision lenticule extraction[J]. BMC Ophthalmol, 2020, 20(1): 110.
[46]	Fernández J, Valero A, Martínez J, et al. Short-term outcomes of small-incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) for low, medium, and high myopia[J]. Eur J Ophthalmol, 2017, 27(2): 153-159.
[47]	Chow SSW, Chow LLW, Lee CZ, et al. Astigmatism Correction Using SMILE[J]. Asia Pac J Ophthalmol (Phila), 2019, 8(5): 391-396.
[48]	Jun I, Kang DSY, Arba-Mosquera S, et al. Comparison of clinical outcomes between vector planning and manifest refraction planning in SMILE for myopic astigmatism[J]. J Cataract Refract Surg, 2020, 46(8): 1149-1158.
[49]	Chen P, Ye Y, Yu N, et al. Comparison of Small Incision Lenticule Extraction Surgery With and Without Cyclotorsion Error Correction for Patients With Astigmatism[J]. Cornea, 2019, 38(6): 723-729.
[50]	Kang DSY, Lee H, Reinstein DZ, et al. Comparison of the Distribution of Lenticule Decentration Following SMILE by Subjective Patient Fixation or Triple Marking Centration[J]. J Refract Surg, 2018, 34(7): 446-452.
[51]	Köse B. Detection of and Compensation for Static Cyclotorsion With an Image-Guided System in SMILE[J]. J Refract Surg, 2020, 36(3): 142-149.
[52]	Yang X, Liu Q, Lin H, et al. Long-term Vector Outcomes of SMILE in Correcting Moderate to High With-the-Rule Astigmatism Under Astigmatism Axis Marked Condition[J]. J Refract Surg, 2020, 36(9): 585-591.
[53]	Assad M, Chazalon T, Naguszewski D, et al. Small Incision Lenticule Extraction (SMILE) for correction of myopic astigmatism[J]. J Fr Ophtalmol, 2020，43(9): 898-906. .
[54]	Primavera L, Canto-Cerdan M, Alio JL, et al. Influence of age on small incision lenticule extraction outcomes[J]. Br J Ophthalmol, 2020，106(3): 341-348.
[55]	Kim BK, Chung YT. Two-year outcomes after full-thickness astigmatic keratotomy combined with small-incision lenticule extraction for high astigmatism[J]. BMC Ophthalmol, 2021, 21(1): 23.

第一作者	手术位置	手术方式	术前散光屈光度(D)	术后散光屈光度(D)
Hou^[10]	角膜	SMILE	-2.41±0.54	-0.14±0.31(-0.09×6.34矢量散光)(术后3个月)
Chan^[1]	角膜	SMILE	-1.08±0.71	-0.24±0.32(术后3个月)
Chan^[1]	角膜	LASIK	-1.37±0.98	-0.06±0.14(术后3个月)
Taneri^[11]	角膜	SMILE	-1.52±0.57	-0.32±0.29(术后3个月)
Sánchez^[12]	角膜	SMILE	-0.48±0.37	-0.31±0.30(术后24个月)
Chan^[13]	角膜	SMILE	-1.60±0.65	±0.50 D内(97%)，±1.00 D内(100%)(术后6个月)
Chan^[14]	角膜	SMILE	-3.42±0.55	-0.27±0.26(术后3个月)
Chan^[14]	角膜	LASIK	-3.47±0.49	-0.22±0.22(术后3个月)
Ivarsen^[15]	角膜	SMILE	-1.76±0.86	-0.50±0.38(术后3个月)
Zhong^[16]	角膜	SMILE	-2.47±0.54	-0.31±0.29(术后4年)
Zhong^[16]	角膜	SMILE	-0.55±0.28	-0.20±0.28(术后4年，低散光组)
Jun^[18]	角膜	TransPRK	-2.84±0.35	-0.31±0.25(术后6个月)
Jun^[18]	角膜	SMILE	-2.90±0.42	-0.37±0.26(术后6个月)
Jun^[18]	角膜	WFG-LASIK	-22.56±1.04	0.42±0.45(术后3个月，矢量差异)
Zhang^[19]	角膜	SMILE	-22.48±0.82	0.36±0.39(术后3个月，矢量差异)
Hiep^[20]	角膜	SMILE	-0.88±0.33	-0.27±0.55(术后3个月，低散光组)
Hiep^[20]	角膜	SMILE	-2.22±0.64	-0.21±0.21(术后3个月，高散光组)
Khalifa^[21]	角膜	SMILE	-1.29±0.85	-0.46±0.28(术后6个月)
Khalifa^[21]	角膜	WFG-LASIK	-1.28±0.81	-0.13±0.20(术后6个月)
Dishler^[22]	角膜	SMILE	-1.52±0.70	-0.18±0.31(术后12个月)
Huang^[24]	角膜	SMILE	-3.15±0.62	-0.58±0.39(术后12个月，高散光组)
Huang^[24]	角膜	SMILE	-0.61±0.43	-0.21±0.21(术后12个月，低散光组)
李庆和^[25]	角膜	SMILE	-3.94±0.39	-0.70±0.21(术后2年)
Yildiz^[27]	角膜	SMILE	-1.50±0.60	-0.43±0.40随访(15±7)个月
Moshirfar^[29]	角膜	SMILE	-1.12±0.60	-0.38±0.38(术后12个月)
陈鹏^[33]	角膜	SMILE	-3.17±0.59	-0.59±0.25(术后6个月)
陈鹏^[33]	角膜	FS-LASIK	-3.15±0.62	-0.69±0.27(术后6个月)
Schallhorn^[35]	角膜	SMILE	-1.53±0.70	-0.22±0.33(术后6个月)
Schallhorn^[35]	角膜	地形图引导-LASIK	-1.19±1.23	-0.19±0.30(术后6个月)
Schallhorn^[35]	角膜	WFG-LASIK	-1.77±1.65	-0.33±0.36(术后6个月)
刘莛^[36]	角膜	SMILE	-0.69±0.44	-0.38±0.38(术后6个月)
刘莛^[36]	角膜	CV-LASEK	-0.50±0.38	-0.33±0.36(术后6个月)
刘莛^[36]	角膜	CV-LASIK	-0.56±0.42	-0.33±0.36(术后6个月)
Zheng^[37]	角膜	SMILE	-0.84±0.47	-0.08±0.17(术后3个月)
Zheng^[37]	角膜	TransPRK	-0.72±0.36	-0.06±0.23(术后3个月)
Gulmez^[38]	角膜	SMILE	-1.64±1.45	-0.04±0.16(术后6个月)
Gulmez^[38]	角膜	WFG-FS-LASIK	-1.52±1.33	-0.03±0.11(术后6个月)
Yang^[40]	角膜	CV-LASIK	-0.95±0.51	-0.11±0.15(术后3个月)
Yang^[40]	角膜	SMILE	-0.91±0.56	-0.16±0.19(术后3个月)
Wan^[41]	角膜	SMILE	-1.95±0.61	-0.10±0.21(术后3个月)
Wan^[41]	晶状体	TICL	-2.06±0.78	-0.30±0.32(术后3个月)
Ganesh^[43]	晶状体	TICL	-1.88±0.88	-0.21±0.32(术后6个月)
Ganesh^[43]	角膜	FS-LASIK	-1.42±0.99	-0.17±0.33(术后6个月)
Ganesh^[43]	角膜	SMILE	-1.08±0.38	-0.19±0.23(术后6个月)

第一作者	手术位置	手术方式	术前散光屈光度(D)	术后散光屈光度(D)
Hou^[10]	角膜	SMILE	-2.41±0.54	-0.14±0.31(-0.09×6.34矢量散光)(术后3个月)
Chan^[1]	角膜	SMILE	-1.08±0.71	-0.24±0.32(术后3个月)
Chan^[1]	角膜	LASIK	-1.37±0.98	-0.06±0.14(术后3个月)
Taneri^[11]	角膜	SMILE	-1.52±0.57	-0.32±0.29(术后3个月)
Sánchez^[12]	角膜	SMILE	-0.48±0.37	-0.31±0.30(术后24个月)
Chan^[13]	角膜	SMILE	-1.60±0.65	±0.50 D内(97%)，±1.00 D内(100%)(术后6个月)
Chan^[14]	角膜	SMILE	-3.42±0.55	-0.27±0.26(术后3个月)
Chan^[14]	角膜	LASIK	-3.47±0.49	-0.22±0.22(术后3个月)
Ivarsen^[15]	角膜	SMILE	-1.76±0.86	-0.50±0.38(术后3个月)
Zhong^[16]	角膜	SMILE	-2.47±0.54	-0.31±0.29(术后4年)
Zhong^[16]	角膜	SMILE	-0.55±0.28	-0.20±0.28(术后4年，低散光组)
Jun^[18]	角膜	TransPRK	-2.84±0.35	-0.31±0.25(术后6个月)
Jun^[18]	角膜	SMILE	-2.90±0.42	-0.37±0.26(术后6个月)
Jun^[18]	角膜	WFG-LASIK	-22.56±1.04	0.42±0.45(术后3个月，矢量差异)
Zhang^[19]	角膜	SMILE	-22.48±0.82	0.36±0.39(术后3个月，矢量差异)
Hiep^[20]	角膜	SMILE	-0.88±0.33	-0.27±0.55(术后3个月，低散光组)
Hiep^[20]	角膜	SMILE	-2.22±0.64	-0.21±0.21(术后3个月，高散光组)
Khalifa^[21]	角膜	SMILE	-1.29±0.85	-0.46±0.28(术后6个月)
Khalifa^[21]	角膜	WFG-LASIK	-1.28±0.81	-0.13±0.20(术后6个月)
Dishler^[22]	角膜	SMILE	-1.52±0.70	-0.18±0.31(术后12个月)
Huang^[24]	角膜	SMILE	-3.15±0.62	-0.58±0.39(术后12个月，高散光组)
Huang^[24]	角膜	SMILE	-0.61±0.43	-0.21±0.21(术后12个月，低散光组)
李庆和^[25]	角膜	SMILE	-3.94±0.39	-0.70±0.21(术后2年)
Yildiz^[27]	角膜	SMILE	-1.50±0.60	-0.43±0.40随访(15±7)个月
Moshirfar^[29]	角膜	SMILE	-1.12±0.60	-0.38±0.38(术后12个月)
陈鹏^[33]	角膜	SMILE	-3.17±0.59	-0.59±0.25(术后6个月)
陈鹏^[33]	角膜	FS-LASIK	-3.15±0.62	-0.69±0.27(术后6个月)
Schallhorn^[35]	角膜	SMILE	-1.53±0.70	-0.22±0.33(术后6个月)
Schallhorn^[35]	角膜	地形图引导-LASIK	-1.19±1.23	-0.19±0.30(术后6个月)
Schallhorn^[35]	角膜	WFG-LASIK	-1.77±1.65	-0.33±0.36(术后6个月)
刘莛^[36]	角膜	SMILE	-0.69±0.44	-0.38±0.38(术后6个月)
刘莛^[36]	角膜	CV-LASEK	-0.50±0.38	-0.33±0.36(术后6个月)
刘莛^[36]	角膜	CV-LASIK	-0.56±0.42	-0.33±0.36(术后6个月)
Zheng^[37]	角膜	SMILE	-0.84±0.47	-0.08±0.17(术后3个月)
Zheng^[37]	角膜	TransPRK	-0.72±0.36	-0.06±0.23(术后3个月)
Gulmez^[38]	角膜	SMILE	-1.64±1.45	-0.04±0.16(术后6个月)
Gulmez^[38]	角膜	WFG-FS-LASIK	-1.52±1.33	-0.03±0.11(术后6个月)
Yang^[40]	角膜	CV-LASIK	-0.95±0.51	-0.11±0.15(术后3个月)
Yang^[40]	角膜	SMILE	-0.91±0.56	-0.16±0.19(术后3个月)
Wan^[41]	角膜	SMILE	-1.95±0.61	-0.10±0.21(术后3个月)
Wan^[41]	晶状体	TICL	-2.06±0.78	-0.30±0.32(术后3个月)
Ganesh^[43]	晶状体	TICL	-1.88±0.88	-0.21±0.32(术后6个月)
Ganesh^[43]	角膜	FS-LASIK	-1.42±0.99	-0.17±0.33(术后6个月)
Ganesh^[43]	角膜	SMILE	-1.08±0.38	-0.19±0.23(术后6个月)

Please choose a citation manager

Content to export